To clarify a point that was brought my attention, a bit of background before the reviews. As readers of the blog have noted, I tend to refrain from giving any kind of numeric score or anything of the sort with my reviews; I feel they're generally not useful if you're looking for a true review rather than seeking to validate your opinion. Thus, it is kind of odd that for my music reviews I've kind of been assigning a score in terms of the number of 5-starred songs.
There's a couple reasons for it. First off, it's an easy metric; it's not some number I'm pulling from nowhere, I don't have to think about it, I just have to look at my iTunes library. Secondly, although I'm reviewing the album as such, the way I listen to music tends to mean that if I don't 5-star a song, it's unlikely I'll ever listen to it; thus, you can view 5-starred songs as the number of songs in an album that I personally would re-listen to (and do).
Perhaps this means I should be doing individual song reviews rather than album, but there's a key reason why I don't, even though it kind of sucks: my backlog of albums means if a song wasn't memorable, as logically follows I don't remember it and probably don't have anything to say about it. Considering my short-story reviews tend to be broken down into individual stories as well as the collection as a whole, it probably follows that albums deserve similar treatment, but the backlog means this would be more work than I'm willing to do.
In the future, once I'm caught up, I may change my methods, but no promises. Keep in mind that while the metric is useful, since if I 5-starred every song on an album (such as the case for At Mount Zoomer) it probably means I think the album as a whole as fantastic, the reverse is not necessarily true. Although I suspect you already know, the written words are more important than a vague number, and although I will continue to provide the number it is by no means the main point of the review.
Showing posts with label Broken Social Scene. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Broken Social Scene. Show all posts
Sunday, December 18, 2011
Friday, December 2, 2011
A Tune for the Worst: Mini-Review Rampage, Music Edition
So in addition to all the books, movies and television shows I've been watching, I've recently got a mad rampage to apparently catch up on all the music I haven't been listening to for most of college. This literally means I've apparently listened to over 40 albums and counting in the past 4 months, and rather than intermixing this huge number with the regular reviews, they're getting their own section until I catch up and stop being so ridiculously behind on my reviews. I don't think I've ever really written music reviews before, so I think this will be interesting; feel free to give feedback.
Subscribe to:
Posts (Atom)